1. Welcome to The Salty Box, a forum to discuss everything related to Marine & Reef Fish keeping in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to be able to join in discussions with others.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon

    Dismiss Notice

Worlds 2nd Dealiest Poison in an aquarium shop near you

Discussion in 'Helpful Articles and Website Links' started by Realist, May 12, 2015.

  1. Realist

    Realist Registered

    Jun 18, 2009
    Likes Received:

    In 2007, a man from Woodbridge, Virginia was rushed into hospital after inhaling an aerosolised version of one of the deadliest poisons on the planet. He was not the victim of a terrorist attack. He wasn’t working in a biohazard laboratory. He was trying to clean out his fish tank.

    The man, who posts on the Reef Central Forums as Steveoutlaw, was trying to get rid of a colony of zoanthids – a relative of corals and sea anemones – that was infesting his aquarium rocks. He had heard that boiling water would do the trick. When he tried it, he accidentally inhaled some of the steam.

    Twenty minutes later, his nose was running and he had a cough. Four hours later, his breathing was laboured and he was headed to the emergency room. By the time he arrived, he was suffering from severe coughing fits and chest pains. He was stabilised, but he developed asthma and a persistent cough, and had to use steroids and an inhaler for at least two months.

    The reason for his sudden illness was palytoxin, a speciality of zoanthids, and the second deadliest poison in the natural world. One gram of the stuff will kill more than a hundred million mice. This poison, liberated by the boiling water, had risen into Steveoutlaw’s airways in a cloud of steam.

    Palytoxin is shrouded in legend. Hawaiian islanders tell of a cursed village in Maui, whose members defied a shark god that had been eating their fellow villagers. They dismembered and burned the god, before scattering his ashes in a tide pool near the town of Hana. Shortly after, a mysterious type of seaweed started growing in the pool. It became known as “limu-make-o-Hana” (deadly seaweed of Hana). If smeared on a spear’s point, it could instantly kill its victims.

    The shark god may have been an elaborate fiction, but in 1961, Philip Helfrich and John Shupe actually found the legendary pool. Within it, they discovered a new species of zoanthid called Palythoa toxica. The limu-make-o-Hana was real, but it wasn’t seaweed – it was a type of colonial anemone. In 1971, Richard Moore and Paul Scheuer isolated the chemical responsible for the zoanthid’s lethal powers – palytoxin. Now, Jonathan Deeds from the US Food and Drug Administration has found that the poison is readily available in aquarium stores.

    Deeds was investigating a case of palytoxin poisoning when he heard about Steveoutlaw’s unfortunate incident. He visited the man, collected a sample of the offending zoanthid, and found that it was indeed heavy with palytoxin. It wasn’t hard to get his hands on more. Deeds bought 15 more colonies from three aquarium stores in the Washington DC area, of the same species that gave Steveoutlaw his whiff of toxic steam. Three of the samples yielded even more poison. Every gram contained enough palytoxin to kill 300,000 mice, or around 80 people.

    Unfortunately, Deeds has no clear message for aquarium owners. Some of the zoanthid species that he tested weren’t toxic at all, and indeed, many people claim to have handled zoanthids for years without problems. However, those that contain palytoxin can kill if even a small amount of the poison gets on the skin. And, as Steveoutlaw found, even breathing in an aerosolised version of the poison is a bad idea. The problem is that telling zoanthids apart is incredibly difficult – Deeds only did it with any degree of certainty using genetic analysis.

    And tracing the origins of these animals isn’t easy either. One of the aquarium owners who Deeds visited said that he got his zoanthids through mixed containers of corals and rock fragments, known as “frags”, with no information about their origins. The animals can be accidentally introduced on unsuspecting rocks. And many aquarium owners will break the rocks up themselves and exchange them between friends.

    As Deeds wrote, “the legendary limu appears to be exacting its ancient curse once again, but this time upon unsuspecting marine home aquarists.” Owners are “often unaware of the deadly poisons they are being exposed to”.

    PS Venom enthusiasts know that the potency of poisons is measured using the LD-50 – the dose that will kill half a group of mice after a set time. The most venomous snake has an LD-50 of 25 micrograms per kilogram of body weight. For tetrodotoxin, the equivalent figure is 8 micrograms. For batrachotoxin, the poison from the skin of poison dart frogs, it’s 2-7 micrograms. For palytoxin, it’s 0.3 micrograms (or 300 nanograms).

    Reference: Deeds, J., Handy, S., White, K., & Reimer, J. (2011). Palytoxin Found in Palythoa sp. Zoanthids (Anthozoa, Hexacorallia) Sold in the Home Aquarium Trade PLoS ONE, 6 (4) DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0018235

    PTX (Paltoxin) is one of the most toxic non-peptide substances known, showing remarkable biological activity even at very low concentration. This toxin and its analogs have become a global concern due to the poison’s effects on animals and especially on humans. Moreover, the recognition that they have a wide geographical distribution and can be found in a variety of seafood has reinforced this concern.

    2.1. Toxicity in Humans: Reports, Symptoms and Routes of Exposure

    Human fatalities due to consumption of seafood suspected to be contaminated with PTX were reported in the Philippines, after consumption of the crab Demania reynaudii, and in Madagascar following consumption of the sardine Herklotsichthys quadrimaculatus. In fact, PTX is now suggested to be the cause of clupeotoxism—a poorly understood toxic syndrome associated with the consumption of clupeoid fish, such as sardines, herrings and anchovies, and characterized by a high mortality rate. Near fatal cases took place after consumption of a smoked fish (Decapterus macrosoma) in Hawaii and after groupers (Epinephelus sp.) or blue humphead parrotfish (Scarus ovifrons) were eaten in Japan. The most commonly reported complications of PTX poisoning appears to be rhabdomyolysis, a syndrome injuring skeletal muscle, causing muscle breakdown, and leakage of large quantities of intracellular (myocyte) contents into blood plasma. Other symptoms associated with PTX poisoning in humans are characterized by a bitter/metallic taste, abdominal cramps, nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, paresthesia, bradycardia, renal failure, cyanosis and respiratory distress. The latter two precede death in fatal cases.

    Recent cases of human intoxication by PTX have shown different contours. In Germany and in the USA, poisoning occurred through dermal absorption, after the victims touched zoanthid corals present in their home aquariums. Moreover, a case of human exposure to PTX via inhalation was also reported regarding a patient who attempted to kill a Palythoa coral in his aquarium. Many other anecdotal evidences of intoxications related with aquarium zoanthids can be found in online marine aquarium forums. Respiratory illness has also occurred when people were exposed to Ostreopsis ovata bloom aerosols during recreational or working activities, in Italy. Symptoms caused by ovatoxin-a from aerosols include fever associated to serious respiratory disturbs, such as bronchoconstriction, mild dyspnea, and wheezes, while conjunctivitis was observed in some cases. These reports highlight the existence of new routes of exposure to PTX and its analogs while it alerts for the risks experienced by aquarium hobbyists by keeping zoanthid in these artificial ecosystems.

    So be very careful when handling Paly's whether it is to frag them or literally just touching them....treat them with the respect they deserve.
    Last edited by a moderator: May 12, 2015
  2. 372xp

    372xp Registered

    Oct 27, 2014
    Likes Received:
    I like my Zoas, guess I'm safe.
  3. Hazey

    Hazey Registered

    Jul 13, 2009
    Likes Received:
    There was a guy back in 2012 off another UK forum who moved a piece of live rock that had some Paly's on the rock & one squirted and it went into his eye. Without going into too much detail he had to have the eye removed & now has a prosthetic eye. :w00t:
  4. reefloat

    reefloat Registered

    Feb 26, 2010
    Likes Received:
    think I will stick to my seahorses thanks
  5. swin

    swin Registered

    Aug 11, 2009
    Likes Received:
    Anyone reading this and wanting rid of their high end Zoas,I will safely dispose of them.......

    Safely into my tank :-D
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice